|
The First
Of The Few (US title Spitfire) |
|
"This
film is brilliantly conceived,
superbly produced and directed,
and has some of the finest
lighting and photography
yet seen in British films.
The flying sequences are
exceptionally effective.
But perhaps outstanding
is the portrait of R. J.
Mitchell by Leslie Howard.
Simple and straightforward,
and therefore most moving
in its appeal, this characterisation
is unforgettable. There
is some fine acting, too,
from David Niven as Crisp
and Rosamund John as Mrs.
Mitchell, and the members
of the supporting cast are
to be complimented on their
performances. The music
was specially written by
William Walton and has served
the subject extremely well."—BFI Monthly Film Bulletin's review, Sept 1942 Pictured:
David Niven as an out-of-work
test pilot, and Leslie
Howard as aircraft designer
R.J. 'Mitch' Mitchell,
meeting up at the Southampton
Supermarine Aviation plant
after the first world
war, to form a partnership
that will help win the
next war. |
|
|
Introduction |
|
|
The
Fim's Subject Matter - The
Historical Background
The idea of the development of the Spitfire as the subject for a patriotic wartime biopic was a natural one. Two thirds of the fighters in the Battle of Britain itself were not the all-metal Spitfire but the canvas-framework Hurricane made by rival firm Hawker, which proved the reliable workhouse of the battle, cheaper and easier to build and re-arm. Yet it was the Vickers Supermarine Spitfire that captured the public imagination. This higher public profile was partly due to its predecessor-prototype, the Vickers Supermarine seaplane, having competed in the international Schneider Cup Trophy races ( held annually in a different national venue) from 1922 onward. After 3 wins, the Supermarine became the permanent Trophy winner, and would break 400mph air-speed records, gaining designer RJ Mitchell a CBE. At a time the RAF was still flying biplanes, Mitchell next developed a monoplane fighter that could fly over 200 miles at a time, climb to over 30,000 feet, cruise at over 350 mph, and dive at over 500 mph, carrying 8 machine guns (later 4 cannon) in its wings. It proved the RAF’s best fighter of the war, and over 20,000 would be built, with nearly two thousand paid for by public subscription. "What is it you need, gentleman?” asked Goering helpfully of his glum Luftwaffe staff officers in mid-1940 when the Battle Of Britain failed to go as well as expected. “Spitfires!” replied one. Goering was not amused, but “Achtung Spitfeuer!” was a genuine alarm call for the German fighters as well as bombers. For while the Hurricanes went after the bombers, the faster Spitfires went for the escorting German fighters. It turned the tide of the war, denying the Germans the air supremacy they needed to invade in 1940. It was the first German defeat of the war. There was also the personal heroism of Mitchell, who had not let a painful terminal illnesss prevent him from overseeing the aircraft’s completion in time for the start of the air war. Len Deighton's history Fighter suggests Mitchell developed that prescience sometimes granted to the dying, in this case a realisation that his plane would be a war-winning weapon. Convinced his aircraft was going to be crucial, he worked non-stop to see it finished in time, and died age 42, within a year of the plane’s first test flight. As his son and biographer Dr Gordon Mitchell summarised his contribution, ‘Without the Spitfire we would have lost the war. And without my father there would have been no Spitfire.’ ![]() Map: The first published Air Ministry account The Battle Of Britain (1941) says that in early August 1940, the Luftwaffe in the first phase of the battle attacked coastal shipping, starting with the dive-bombing of convoys off Wight and Bournemouth by up to 130 Stukas, switching to attacking ports a few days later with raids on Weymouth and Portland. But the Stukas proved easy prey for the RAF Spitfires and Hurricanes. The Luftwaffe switched to bombing airfields using fighter-bombers, a tactic that could soon have put the RAF front-line bases [shown above on an official MOI map] out of action. However, they changed tactics to target London and other port-cities such as Southampton with heavy bombers, allowing Fighter Command time to recover and return to its previous effectiveness. The RAF fighters were directed or ‘vectored’ to the enemy by Britain's new radar system (developed not far from the film's location airfeld), a secret the film is careful not to give away. Leslie
Howard's Fateful Flight
The film
was a considerable success,
but would be Leslie Howard's
final screen role. On
31st May 1943, Howard
and his manager took a
commercial flight to Lisbon
to attend the film's premiere
in Portugal, where it
received a best-film medal.
He also discussed the
possibility of an Anglo-Spanish
co-production about Columbus,
and flew back June 1st.
Around noon, the BOAC/KLM
DC3 passenger-transport
plane carrying him and
other civilians was attacked
by half a dozen German
fighters. It broke up
in mid-air over the Bay
Of Biscay, and everyone
aboard was lost. Germany
released a statement the
shootdown was due to a
misidentification.Since then, it has been suggested that this was really an assassination, a reprisal for Howard's success in making patriotic wartime films, especially First Of The Few, where the idea of killing him in a way demonstrating German mastery of the skies might have particular appeal. That is, in one fell swoop the Luftwaffe publicly downed the producer, director and star of a current propaganda film promoting British air supremacy. The alternative explanation was offered by Churchill after the war that incompetent enemy agents at Lisbon had misidentified Howard and his chubby, balding manager as Churchill and his bodyguard, both of whom were visiting Algiers at the time ("a tragedy which much distressed me"). This theory features in TV historical documentary series like Churchill's Bodyguard. (The scenario here is that Churchill was due to fly home from the Algiers Conference that day in a US Liberator bomber flying the same route over the sea, but heard of the assassination plan via Enigma intelligence decrypts and flew home a day later, using the excuse of a mechanical fault to protect the Enigma code-breaking secret.) Portugal being neutral in the war, Lisbon was able to run commercial flights used by Axis as well as neutral and Allied VIPs (Casablanca fans will remember how the plot revolves around the daily Lisbon plane). Being used by both sides at VIP level as well by neutrals, these flights normally operated without interference. Nevertheless, the flight out Howard originally planned to take was also attacked, managing to escape at wavetop level despite damage. Repaired, it was this same aircraft that was shot down on its return journey. Churchill himself later commented it was hard to understand the Germans could have been so stupid as to believe their agent's report he was travelling on a neutral civilian airliner. The idea agents believed Churchill, as the Nazis' number-one assassination target, would take an ordinary passenger flight via Lisbon over the Atlantic is not a very likely scenario in itself. And the fact the plane was attacked on the way out contradicts the story. However, an epilogue to a 2007 Radio 4 play [27/04/07] about the shootdown mystery, The Wrong Hero? by Mark Burgess, noted the Gov't recently decided to keep the official documents on this matter secret till 2025. This seems to add credence to the scenario suggested by Churchill's Bodyguard the Prime Minister was able to fly home unmolested as the Germans believed for several days they had already shot him down, not realising or believing they had killed Howard. Howard's son, the Dorset-resident actor and art collector Ronald Howard, in his 1981 biography In Search Of My Father, suggests the Germans actually got the idea of killing him in this way from Hamlet (from which Howard did readings in Lisbon). In the play, the thoughtful young prince who disputes the legitimacy of the new regime is sent across the sea to be assassinated on a pretext. Earlier, the turncoat broadcaster known as Lord Haw-Haw (whose voice is heard in the film, and who had in 1939 lived outside Ringwood, near RAF Ibsley where Howard would film) had announced Howard was on a death-list, and would be liquidated in good time. The headline in Goebbels's propaganda newspaper was "Pimpernel Howard has made his last trip," a reference to his update of his Scarlet Pimpernel role in his previous anti-Nazi propaganda film Pimpernel Smith. There are also claims Howard had a real-life 'Pimpernel' role of his own, that he was on a secret diplomatic mission, the Columbus film project being a front for negotiating tactical concessions from Franco, who had been making discreet political overtures to Britain. The actor's son suggests the shootdown may have been a warning to Franco. German
radio described the shoot-down
as an "error of judgement."
It was certainly that,
in ways the Germans did
not foresee, for Howard
was also a nationally-known
figure in America from
his role in Gone With
The Wind (which ran
in cinemas throughout
the war). He was the very
image of the gentle, normally
harmless English aristocrat,
and killing him would
have done the Germans
no good at all in the
propaganda department.
Howard was shot down just
as the film premiered
in the USA, and US as
well as British reviews
often mention the fact
its director-star was
killed when the Luftwaffe
shot down an unarmed civilian
passenger plane. The incident
validated warnings by
Howard and others that
fascism was simply a veneer
for a murderous tyranny.
With an output including
The Scarlet Pimpernel,
Pygmalion, 49th Parallel,
Pimpernel Smith, The Gentle
Sex, and The
Lamp Still Burns, Ronald
Howard describes his father
as "Britain's most
powerful and effective
propagandist." As
well as a tribute to R.J.
Mitchell, the film and
the popular concert suite
adapted from its music
score thus also are a
memorial to another talented
patriotic Englishman,
Leslie Howard.
|
The
Making Of The Film The First Of The Few tells the story of the birth of the Spitfire, its US title being simply Spitfire). While the film dramatises how the fighter–plane came into being, of interest here is how the film itself came into being. The film was produced and directed by its star Leslie Howard, who had returned from Hollywood when war broke out. (He had played in a number of Hollywood A-films, including The Petrified Forest opposite Bogart, and Gone With The Wind.) Howard spent the rest of his career devoted to making British mainstream cinema instrumental in the war effort, until he himself was shot down by the Luftwaffe in 1943 [see inset left, below]. Like others then prominent in Britain’s pre-war film industry, Howard had a Hungarian background. Though not a direct émigré like the Korda brothers and their circle, he proved just as patriotic as those who had seen directly what totalitarianism was capable of. Born in London in 1893, he was of Jewish-Hungarian descent, born Leslie Howard Stainer or Steiner, and grew up in Vienna. Though he had fought in WWI (until he fell victim to shell shock), he had actually been in films since 1914, and his brother Arthur was an actor in comedy films. His boyish good looks offset by his high forehead, he began to play a particular type of Englishman. He had taken an interest in directing early on, and formed a company called Minerva Films with actor-turned-director Adrian Brunel. In
Britain his best-known pre-war
roles were as The Scarlet
Pimpernel for Korda in
1935, and in 1938 as Professor
Henry Higgins in GB Shaw’s
social satire Pygmalion
(the basis of My
Fair Lady). After Howard
returned from Hollywood, he
had produced, directed and
starred in an updated ' Scarlet
Pimpernel' story, Pimpernel
Smith (1941), where an
ineffectual-seeming archaeology
professor helps people escape
the Nazis. To get the Spitfire biopic off the ground, Howard approached Churchill, who gave him a ‘To Whom It May Concern’ letter of support, and with this Howard got backing from the new Rank Studios and GFD, then the largest British distributors. Howard also got his old partner Adrian Brunel, now working for the MOI, as ‘production consultant’ to help film and incorporate the documentary footage [see inset left, below]. For the main, soundstage-shot scenes, he hired Korda's lighting cameraman Georges Perinal, with Jack Hildyard as operator. He also got star David Niven leave from front-line service in the Army to play the co-starring role of test pilot ‘Geoffrey Crisp,' who was based mainly on Vickers’s test pilots Jeffrey Quill (also an RAF veteran) and 'Mutt' Summers. It was Jeffrey Quill [pictured left in a MkI] who flew the Spitfire in the aerobatics scene where in front of the RAF brass the prototype is put through its paces, showing it can indeed climb to 10,000 feet and dive at over 500 mph. Major Niven had already been posted to the south coast, being based behind Poole Harbour while training his own mobile squadron in stay-behind guerrilla fighting in case the Germans invaded. Niven was still under contract to US producer Samuel Goldwyn, who had released him to appear in exchange for US distribution rights. Graham Lord's 2003 Niv: The Authorised Biography Of David Niven says Goldwyn wrote to his star in August 1943 to say he would not have approved the deal if he had known the part Niven was going to play. "Spitfire was a disappointment to me," adding, "I spent two months cutting it and took out about forty minutes, in addition to putting in some closeups of you." Lord's own verdict was it was "Niv's first major British movie and possibly his best performance to date," but it's likely Niven had a larger co-starring role in the original script. Lord's authorised biography says that whereas Niven's own memoir The Moon's A Balloon has him spending only 4 weeks filming it, his army records show he was released from duties for 5 months. It's also likely Goldwyn expected a more conventional glossy Hollywood product. However regarding the idea of making the film in the US, the actor's son Ronald Howard has said, "the subject would have been totally unrealistic in Hollywood which had neither the technical resources nor the experience of war, neither the Spitfires nor the pilots who had flown them in battle." Filming in England with Churchill's support, Howard was also able to get official RAF access to film real Spitfires, both being built and in action on Fighter Command airfields. This included getting actual pilots to appear in brief speaking roles. Hence, the film’s credits and posters describe the film as "Starring ... Leslie Howard / David Niven / “Pilots & Other Personnel Of RAF Fighter Command.” |
|
The
Film’s Use Of
Creative License |
|
The
Film’s Soundtrack
And Score After Howard’s, the greatest artistic contribution to the film is the music of Sir William Walton (1902-83). Having written the 1937 coronation march ‘Crown Imperial’, he had been exempted from military service on the grounds he could serve his country better in its hour of need by writing stirring patriotic music for films deemed ‘of national importance’. This was one of these, and his music proved so effective and memorable that in 1943 he turned its main themes into a still-popular concert suite, the ‘Spitfire Prelude And Fugue.’ When Howard, busy elsewhere, sent his Supervising Editor Sidney Cole [see panel below] to tell Walton what music Howard felt the film needed, Walton listened, then replied simply, "Oh, I see, Leslie wants a lot of notes", and went off and wrote the Spitfire Fugue. (To say this fast-tempo piece comprises 'a lot of notes' would be an understatement.) Although many reviewers seem to think Walton's musical contribution consisted only of the Prelude and Fugue parts reproduced on the concert suite, his underscore actually consists of around 20 different cues. The concert-suite themes are basically those heard under the main and end titles (the ‘Prelude’ part) and the race-against-time plane-building montage (the 'Fugue' part), with a violin-solo interlude interpolated to represent the dying Mitchell. Prelude and Fugue apart, Walton here tends to a similar approach to that of Bernard Herrmann in his 1941 Citizen Kane score, where the music is close to ambient or source music, but often used in a slightly satiric way. (Walton had earlier written some ‘parodic’ music for the concert hall that got him attacked critically as 'a musical joker’. ) Despite Walton’s ability to compose stately themes reminiscent of Elgar, he preferred a lighter touch. He may well have disliked military music as the theme music of bellicose fascism, for both conventional military-parade marches and Wagnerian melodrama are satirised in his score. (His score for another film on the same subject, the 1969 film Battle Of Britain, was largely replaced by the producers as unsuitable. Since restored on both DVD and soundtrack CD, it is - triumphal grand finale apart - notably more light-hearted and humanistic than Ron Goodwin’s martial snaredrum-heavy replacement.) After the film’s opening titles, the historical scene-setting prologue is scored in a mock-Wagnerian medley as the blitzkrieg overruns Europe and Nazi bigwigs make boastful speeches about conquering Britain next. After the opening airfield scene, Walton provides a cue of the ‘celestial’ sort (harps) used in films to set up dream-sequences and memory flashbacks, and this continues into the south-coast clifftop scene where Mitchell is watching the gulls. Similar music is also used in the ‘passage-of-time’ bridging montages. The music introducing the film’s narrator, Crisp (who doubles as the film’s comic relief in his ladies-man debacles), is initially reminiscent of ‘Pop Goes The Weasel.’ With the various Schneider Cup seaplane races, we get simulated source music (an American march for the Baltimore race, an Italian one for Venice) combined with ‘suspense’ music in the race montages. There are also some incidental musical ‘stings’, as with Crisp’s crash (and later, Mitchell’s moment of death). After the third and permanent trophy win, in Italy, the film’s own stately march is first heard as underscore. In the German holiday sequence, an onscreen Bavarian 'oompah' band suddenly turns serious and starts playing a ‘Strength Through Joy’ march for a Nazi-youth glider-club marchout scene (cut from US prints). This is at once followed by a waltz to set up what at first appears to be a congenial dinner with top German aviators. The violin theme representing Mitchell’s physical decline is first heard next as Crisp escorts the overworked inventor home. After he gets the news he has only a short time to live, the fast-tempo fugue strings theme appears (rather warbly in its first iteration here) over the first plane-building montage. (British cinema of the 1930s-40s often featured industrial montages set to music using French cinema’s “ballet mechanique” concept, and as the brass joins in, you can almost hear the hammering of a busy factory floor.) The violin ‘elegy’ theme returns the moment he sees the ‘Guernica’ headline. (See scene breakdown, right.) There is then an immediate return to the race-against-time plane-building fugue music, which builds up to a triumphal climax with the ‘march’ theme heard behind the sounds of the real Spitfire, before subsiding into a quiet ending. The ‘celestial’ music returns for his death scene, and finally provides a slighty unworldly overtone to the stately ‘Waltonian’ grand finale of the film’s fadeout against a cloudscape illuminated by fan-shaped rays of light. ![]() The
Film's Use Of Montage The third artistic contribution that makes the film work is the film's editing, especially its many montage sequences, by Supervising Editor Sidney Cole (1908-1998), and Howard's old partner Adrian Brunel (1892-1958). Listed as the film's Production Consultant, Brunel was known as a 'film doctor' patching up films editorially. The scene-bridging montages are an essential element, for like many biographical films the film is necessarily episodic. Cole and Brunel's montages, full of optical dissolves, do more than simply convey the passage of time. There are three key montages that bring the film alive cinematically. The first of these opens the film with a scene-setting prologue on the fall of Western Europe to Nazi aggression. This begins with the main titles over a cloudscape with Europe seen from the heavens. Then Nazi bigwigs make pompous speeches superimposed on a background map of Europe over which 'mediaeval tyranny' has spread as a black stain, and we cut straight to a title announcing 'Zero Day' in the Battle of Britain, thus cuing the opening scene at RAF Ibsley. Towards the end comes the two-part documentary montage that inspired Walton's 'Spitfire Fugue' and which form the film's cinematic climax. Brunel shot the factory scenes himself for these. In the first montage, we see the prototype being assembled under Mitchell's supervision, with wings, cockpit, and then engine fitted. In the second part, as the plane takes shape, at first we hear only Walton's music, then the roar of the fighter's Rolls Merlin engine is also heard as this is 'run in', followed by the rapid-fire chatter of the wing-mounted Vickers machine-guns as these are sight-tested. The wing-guns are test-fired at a white cloth-strip target with an enemy-bomber silhouette painted on it. We see the machine guns firing from inside the wing (with wing cover off), then from below to show hundreds of spent .303 cartridges spilling out below onto the tarmac, and back to over the now-covered wing. If you look carefully, you can see in the background the cloth target actually catches fire from the friction of the Spitfire's fusillade, and the image fades out as the dream of the bird that can 'spit fire' is fulfilled. The montage ending with the testing of the wing-mounted machine-guns and the Spit's first appearance as it is wheeled out the hangar brings the first 90 minutes to a climax, in one of the great sequences of British wartime cinema. The 3 documentary shots which conclude the Fugue montage last only a few seconds but show the inventor's dream finally realized, as we both see and hear his machine literally "spit fire." |
Scene
Breakdown With Production
Notes 1.
A prologue portrays the
current war almost as a
religious crusade, against
a return of 'mediaeval tyranny'.
We hear excerpts of speeches
of Lord Haw-Haw, Churchill,
Hitler, Goebbels, and Goering,
all setting the scene for
this pivotal moment in history
in mid 1940 - "a fateful
summer for the world." |
| Further
Study Locations: Actual pre-war test flights were conducted at Southampton Eastleigh Airport, and a campaign is underway to have it renamed 'Southampton RJ Mitchell Airport.' The actual wartime RAF aerodromes seen are now history (cf now-vanished RAF Warmwell in mid-Dorset, shown on the wartime map above left, which once lay at OS 758/888), but the remnant of RAF Ibsley is viewable. RAF Ibsley Historical Group's memorial plaque on the NW corner has an engraved map showing the airfield layout, viewable online here, and another website with map and aerial photos is here. The village of Ibsley itself is on the E side of the Avon Valley, on the outskirts of the New Forest, along the old road paralleling the A338 dual carriageway running N from Christchurch to Salisbury. You can just glimpse the airfield Control Tower from the road, the field itself being largely now a water-filled gravel pit. The RAF Ibsley Historical Group is seeking funds from English Heritage to restore the ruined Control Tower, as the last survivor of its kind. |
|
|
A distinctive design feature was the Spitfire's elliptical wing. In 2006, the Spitfire came third in the Design Museum's 'British Design Icons' contest. |
EnvoiThe image of a Spitfire soaring protectively over English downland has become an iconic one. It symbolises the more pastoral approach to English patriotism adopted during WW2 in works of art. Its most complete representation is still in The First Of The Few, where the Spitfire first soars over peaceful English countryside in its maiden test flight. Above: You can click on the image above to view a Battle Of Britain commemorative webpage I once did on this theme for another project, with a link to the Imperial War Museum. (Clicking 'Refresh' or Reload on your browser bar will restart the timelined animation sequence, but you need to scroll down the page to see it all.) |
Top | Email Us | Film Locations Home | South Central MediaScene